Showing posts with label food. Show all posts
Showing posts with label food. Show all posts

10 Dec 2011

FDI in Indian Retail I



After 2 decades of procrastination, it seemed that India was finally opening up its underdeveloped retail market to Foreign Direct Investment (FDI). The landmark announcement  was  made  on Nov 24th, when  the  Union  Cabinet  cleared the bill allowing 100% FDI in Single-brand retail (think: IKEA, LV, Apple, etc.), up  from 51% as it was until now. The announcement also  included a controversial  decision to allow 51% FDI in Multi-brand retail (think: Wal-Mart, Tesco, Carrefour, etc.).

While FDI in Single-brand retail segment has been welcomed, Multi-brand segment has caused hysteria in the Parliament, and cascaded on to the streets with retail stores across the country closing down for a day in protest against FDI (protesting seems to be the biggest trend of the year 2011). These strikes were organized by wholesale traders’ unions and other middlemen in the retail supply-chain, the biggest losers if the likes of Wal-Mart & Tesco come in. The non-functioning parliament cost the nation Rs. 1.5 Cr (15 million) per day, but the opportunity cost of loss of productivity & the cost of impairment of India’s reputation are anybody’s guess. The Prime Minister’s executive authority has now been questioned too. As his Congress Party pitched the idea to other MPs and citizens citing benefits like job creation and modernization of Indian retail, they did not get any support even from their own allies, let alone the opposition parties. The naysayers’ argument was that FDI in Multi-brand retail would put millions out of smaller shopkeepers (kirana shops) out of business, and also that international giants will form monopolies and exploit farmers.

Why would anyone in their right minds participate in such folly? Is it confusion caused by political noise? Or is it ignorance that’s fueling such dissent? Don’t people know better? Do they lack independent judgment? I think it’s absurd that people protest against something that they would actually benefit from. So in this post, I will share my views on the matter. As you can probably tell already, I not only support it, but also encourage it to be rolled out ASAP. I do think that a few tweaks should be made to the finer print. But before l share my views, let me list down some of the features of what the Government’s proposal says.

Salient features of the Multi-brand Retail FDI :
  1. There has to be a minimum investment of $ 100 million.
  2. 50% of the total investment has to be in back-end infrastructure.
  3. Stores are permitted to open only in cities with a population of at least 1 million (10 Lac) people.
  4. At least 30% of manufactured / processed products must be sourced from Indian MSMEs.
  5. The government retains the right to be the first to source agricultural produce.
  6. The Bill is just an enabler; it is essentially up to individual states to allow or disallow the retailers to open shop.
Salient features of the Single-brand Retail FDI :
  1. Brand must already have presence in other countries too.
  2. 30% mandatory sourcing from Indian MSMEs.
  3. Must be branded during manufacturing.
  4. Investor must be Brand Owner, and not a franchisee or a regional license holder.


At this point, allow me to throw some light on the situation. The backdrop has been that of a global slowdown, with Indian government being in the news for all the wrong reasons, ranging from scams to policy paralysis. With painfully high inflation, stunting economic growth and a weakened Rupee, permitting FDI was the Indian government’s stimulus package. Here’s how. Firstly, it attracts long-term capital into India which is both, less speculative and more productive in nature. Such capital investments in India (by both, international and domestic businesses) had declined recently. Secondly, this move would have brought technological knowhow and spur backward integration in organized retail in India. This would lead to drastic improvements in supply-chain infrastructure, especially in the domain of perishable goods, by replacing intermediaries who do not add any value with those who do. Before you jump to conclude that intermediaries are not being removed, but just replaced, let me explain what I mean. Consider the following numbers:

  • Currently, there are about 5-7 intermediaries between the farmers and the retailers. This causes the price of vegetables and fruits to increase multiple folds. For instance, potatoes cost only Rs. 2/Kg in Nasik, Maharashtra (closer to the farms) but by the time it reaches New Delhi, consumers pay Rs. 18/Kg for it. That is a 9-fold price difference, and neither the farmers, nor the customers benefit from it.
  • About 40-45 % of the perishable food produce gets perishes before even making it to the marketplace. This shows the value-destruction of the current intermediaries.
  • According to rating agency CRICIL, India’s organized retail loses Rs. 10,000 Cr ($ 2 bn) annually due to wastage, mostly of perishable products like fruits, vegetables, fish, meat & poultry. While 15% of these losses occur at the farmland itself, another 25% is lost during transportation.
  • The ratio of traders to actual retailers is 0.001. This means that for every 1000 retailers, there is only 1 trader. So the argument that single stores, or (Kiranas) will shut is flawed, and the number of traders who lose jobs is overhyped too. The intermediaries (about 15,000 currently) won’t be left unemployed; instead, they will get new jobs that actually add value in the supply-chain. Direct sourcing from the farmers can reduce supply-chain costs by 10-15%.
  • About 85% of all farmers own only about 2.5 hectares of land or less. This gives then no bargaining power, and they end up getting exploited by the agents. Also, they are not working on a contract-basis, but on a contact-basis. Hence, they have no defense against current exploitation either. On the other hand, for example, Tata Chemicals helps the farmers working with Trent (contractually of-course) in assessing their land, and recommending the most suitable fertilizers and other technologies that could help farmers get a higher output from their land.
  • According to consultancy firm A.T. Kearney, organized retail is currently only 7% of the $435 billion (approx Rs. 21 Lac Crore) Indian retail market but is expected to rise to 21% within the next few years. Food accounts for 70-80% of this. This is led by a consumption class of 400 million people with rising disposable incomes, and a steady rate of urbanization. 

Considering the above numbers, the case for organized retail is self-imposing. Indian conglomerates such as the Tatas, AV Birla, Reliance, etc have already been trying to strengthen their foothold in the Indian organized retail market. While they and other domestic players like Bharti, Future Group, etc. are already trying to eliminate the intermediaries, their scale of operations is not significant enough to bring about a substantial change in the condition of the farmers, or curb prices on a national scale. Furthermore, they lack adequate experience and technical knowhow in the retail domain to introduce any breakthrough innovations. The international players, on the other hand, can leverage their experience to bring the much needed reforms in the Indian supply-chain network by innovating logistics, introducing cold-storage systems, food-processing, IT systems, etc. 

Thirdly, Micro & Small-Scale Enterprises (MSMEs) will have a direct market to sell to and therefore will reap benefit similar to the farmers. In fact, the challenge for them will be to scale up their operations to meet the demand of these organized retailers. In such a scenario, they too will ramp up production scale and hire more workers. Some might even innovate and adopt newer technologies, thereby generating a larger positive spillover effect in their community.

The fourth benefit of FDI in retail will come in the form of a positive externality of making our workforce more employable. At present, several employers often complain of India’s current workforce lacking several key skills and hence being unemployable. Many workers in the current retail sector will not lose jobs like the politicians have been suggesting, but instead, be hired for their experience & understanding of the Indian consumer, and get trained for the new retail landscape. According to reports from the consultancy firm Boston Consulting Group (BCG), organized retail could right away create about 10 million jobs – 4 million direct and another 6 million indirect jobs. It would generate additional incomes of Rs. 73,000 Cr (approx $14.6 billion), and consumers would save about 1.5 Lac Crore (approx $31.25 billion) annually in their shopping bill. However this is only possible if significant scale is achieved and technology is applied, which is only achievable by allowing FDI in Multi-brand retail. The illustration below shows the current employment generated by Retail trade in some cities. These numbers will only grow post FDI reforms.   

These are just some of the more obvious benefits that we can foresee already, and I am sure there are more too. But there’s more to the retail FDI story than just the numbers I presented. I will do a follow-up post on this topic highlighting the bigger picture, and state my case as to why I feel FDI is going to benefit India. Until then, I leave you with this Illustration which appeared in Hindustan Times, showing how some other countries have opened their doors to FDI in their Retail Industry.  

21 Nov 2011

Food-O-nomics II



In my previous post, I tried to explain the dynamics of food inflation in India and touched upon the factors that influenced food prices. In this post, I plan to wrap that up by looking at what could happen to food prices if some issues are vigilantly addressed. So without wasting any time, let’s look at what these elements are:



1.    Boost infrastructure.



Initially I thought it would be a good idea for the government to start developing farm-to-market infrastructure, especially cold storage and logistics network, but then on 2nd thoughts, I think its best that instead of government trying to do it themselves (read: scam-alert), they let specialists do it, even if with a profit motive. With FDI in (100% in single-brand and 51% in multi-brand) retail finally being allowed, it is expected that international majors interested in setting up shop in India will heavily invest in setting up “back-end infrastructure.” In fact, the new FDI rules would require them to invest 50% of their total investment (US$ 100million minimum) in back-end infrastructure, including storage, processing, distribution, warehousing, logistics etc. What these heavyweights would bring to the table is not only the much-needed capital, but also technical knowhow that might not have been possible otherwise. What would be the result of this? Higher output of-course! In due time (don’t expect miracles overnight), thanks to unclogged bottlenecks (& minimal waste), not only will the quantity of output rise, but the quality of output will see drastic improvements.


2.   Encourage education among farmers to foster innovation and improve agricultural productivity.

Encouraging more participation in farming and agriculture is another way that the government can increase supply in the food economy. The condition of our farmers (thousands of suicides every year) is known to all (partially thanks to Bollywood). But instead of blaming and criticizing the government (which seems to be in vogue these days), I simply think that if the farmers’ children are given incentives to learn modern Agriculture, perhaps on a tertiary level, then we would have this new generation of farmers who will be technologically more advanced than their parents and will become the leaders of agricultural innovation. Such a trend (on a smaller scale) is already visible in some sections of the economy where individuals are catering to the demand for organic vegetables and fruits, and other niche food items. The key take-away here is that education will lead to development and innovation, and there is a strong case for encouraging education in the agricultural sector. The Indian Institute of Horticulture Research in Bangalore, an institute of the Indian Council of Agricultural Research (ICAR) has developed new techniques of improving the quality of output. Furthermore, innovative practices that enhance efficiency and boost yields have been recommended by the ICAR but due to the bureaucratic bottlenecks, these lab-innovations could never actually make it to the farmers' fields. That being said, it is only fair that I give the government due credit for the fact that they have supported R&D in horticulture in the last 25 years by increasing the R&D budget allowance in every Five Year Plan. That support however gets negated somewhere between the labs & the fields, and as mentioned already, most of the innovations never get to see the light of day. If this broken bridge is resurrected, and more of these innovations are implemented on a commercial scale, there will be a certain boost in output, both in quantity and quality. I personally believe that cultivating education, innovation & productivity should in-fact be among the prime areas of focus for the government because it is no longer just rice, wheat and course grains that are fueling food inflation, but higher protein-based items such as fruits, vegetables, dairy, poultry and meat.


Both the recommendations above, in their own ways, lead to an increase in supply of food. Lets look at a graph similar to the one used in my previous post (Food-O-nomics) and see how an increase in supply affects the demand-supply-price dynamics of the food economy. 




As you can see from the graph, an increase in supply from S to S1 causes the quantity of output to rise from Q to Q2 and also brings the prices down from P to P2. 


It is worth noting that considering the size of India's population and landmass available to farmers, a sizable rise in output can make India a much greater player in the global food economy than what it is today. 


17 Nov 2011

Food-O-nomics


For India, one of the crucial talking points of the year 2011 has been the sharp rise in food prices. So it’s only fair that I do a piece on this topic as well. However, through this piece, I would like to go to the basics, (ignore political bias and pragmatic difficulties) and look at the demand-supply dynamics in the food economy. So without further ado, let’s look at the situation we have at hand.

Since the demand and supply of food (or any other good/service for that matter) is dependent on its Price (P) and quantity available (Q), we plot a graph using P & Q, and proceed from there. Let’s say that the national demand for food is represented by the Demand Curve (D) while the national supply of food is represented by the Supply Curve (S). As we can see, D & S meet at point O, which is called the Equilibrium Point, at which the demand for food is matched by supply, and hence at quantity Q, its price is P.

For those who are already confused, let me give you a simplistic example. Assume that the demand & supply curves for Apples meet at point O, where the quantity of apples produced is 100 dozens and the price per dozen is only Rs. 20. Therefore, we can say that in the market of apples, equilibrium is at :
Q = 100 dozen      &        P = Rs. 20 / dozen 




Now using this framework, let us now see how different external events affect the prices that we as consumers have to pay for food.  

1. Government implements a rural job guarantee scheme (NREGA) which promises 100 days of employment every year to adults in rural households at Rs. 120 per day. 

Since agricultural labor prices were traditionally determined by market forces (i.e. supply and demand), they were lower than what they are now. Hence, schemes like the NREGA have artificially inflated the labor prices, which the farmers have to pay. Since the farmer only has limited funds, he has to lower other costs to accommodate the rise in labor costs, or scale down his output. Since most of the other costs cannot be lowered much further, the only alternative that remains is to lower output.

2. Poor infrastructure, & the government lacking willingness (or ability) to reform has led to severe wastage of farm output. 

Shoddy logistics, inadequate supply-chain mechanisms and substandard storage facilities have resulted in more than 30% the fruits and vegetable produce to rot before they even reach the market. All the while, the government eagerly spending Rs. 40,000 Crore (US$ 8.1 billion) on the NREGA scheme alone, and another 80,000 crore (US$ 16.2 billion) on fertilizer subsidies, but has failed to develop agricultural infrastructure. Instead of "spending" in that space, it is asking private companies to "invest" in such infrastructure. Can anyone else also see the absurdity in this scenario? At the end of the day, the implication here is simple - Loss of Output. 


Both the scenarios mentioned above have one common element. There is a fall in output because of either government action, or government inaction (don't you love such irony). Or in other words, there is a decline in the Supply of output. On the graph, this is represented by a shift of the supply curve to the left (inward shift). As you can see, with demand holing up, a fall in supply causes prices to rise. 


You can see that as the supply curve S shifts to S2, a new equilibrium point (O2) is formed where the quantity of output declines to Q2, and prices rise to P2.

I have only mentioned two examples, but there are many more issues that cause the output to fall, and a decline in supply. For instance, the Food Security Act (FSA) mandates the government to procure most of the annual grain output (and then import some more), to sell at subsidized rates. The prices are set using what's come to known as the 3-2-1 Model, where each family will pay Rs. 3/Kg for Rice, Rs. 2/kg for Wheat & Re. 1/Kg for Coarse Grain. At an estimated cost of close to Rs. 1.2 Trillion, experts are warning that the program can impact prices not just in India but the whole world. But the most imperative question at this point however is that how is the program going to be paid for and what impact is this going to have on India's fiscal deficit? 

However, what I have said so far is only a 1-dimensional view of the food market i.e.  only Supply side issues. For a diligent view, it is crucial to look at the demand side of the equation too. So let's go back to the NREGA; one consequence of this scheme has been that the rural incomes have risen leaving them with more money, which they can use to buy, among other things, more food (or some more tobacco to chew) for the household. This would increase the overall demand for food. Bear in mind that the government's Food Security Act only covers rice, what & coarse grains, and not fruits, vegetables or any meat/poultry. Hence despite FSA's exhaustive efforts, rural households will still have to pay market prices for the other food items. On the graph, this situation would be illustrated by a shift of the demand curve to the right (outward shift).


And somewhat like the last graph, observe that as the demand curve D shifts to D2, the new equilibrium point (O2) is formed where the quantity of output rises to Q2, and prices rise to P2.


I don't like repeating myself, but I have no choice except stating the obvious conclusion - government actions yet again have caused food prices to rise. Rising rural incomes may undeniably be a positive outcome, but its consequences are not. While the average GDP growth over the last 5 years has been 8.6% & the average population growth has been 1.3% (read: demand growth), the average annual growth in the agricultural sector has been a measly 3.1% (read: inadequate supply growth). An economic survey shows that post liberalization in 1991, annual per-capita production of food grains has declined 11% from 208 kg in 1996-97 to 186 kg in 2009-10.  


In my next post, I will take this discussion further and show you the solution to this predicament, and talk about measures that the government should take if it seriously wants to lower food prices in a sustainable manner.


13 Nov 2011

Surprise Surprise.. Targets Missed.. Again !!

The purpose of this post is to recognize & be able to connect various dots, and draw a clearer picture of the issues that paralyzing the Indian economy. My intention is merely to instigate a desire to comprehend issues that are rooted much deeper than what we read in our daily papers. In other words, I want to raise a few themes that I believe are all inter-related and probably, the root of several problems that the Indian economy faces. 

So for starters, let me remind you of the high inflation numbers that have hurt not just the poor, but also the middle-class – perhaps more than they have hurt the poor. Traditionally, I would have gone about this by researching for CPI & WPI statistics and analyze them from that point onwards. Instead, this time I chose to simply talk to people about where they felt the pinch of inflation the most personally, just to feel the pulse of the problem. Most common areas – as expected – were food, petrol, & housing. Consequentially, their utilities bill has gone up, and savings have been dented. We will look at each of these in greater detail later.  

Now let’s leave inflation & monetary policy transmission alone for a while and look at the fiscal policy facet of our economy. Let’s begin with a special mention of the various populist schemes our government has crafted to win the hearts of the nation’s vote bank. These include the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (aka NREGA), and the Minimum Support Price (MSP) given to farmers, & various subsidies on kerosene, diesel and gas, fertilizers, & food items, etc. With elections not too far away, there are more such populist schemes in the pipeline, and not surprisingly, the government has no clue of how the schemes are going to be paid for. The Finance Ministry’s had already used up 70% of the annual target of the fiscal deficit in September, and announced that it needed to borrow Rs. 528 billion. This means that while the fiscal deficit target presented during the annual budget was 4.6% of the GDP, it is more likely to be around 5.5% according to experts. However, our ever-optimistic government still maintains that they can keep it under 5%.

Furthermore, they claim that the additional borrowing has nothing to do with the fact that they have so far failed (anybody surprised?) in their plans to divest their stake in PSUs. The budgeted divestment target was Rs. 400 billion for the fiscal year, raised, primarily by issuing IPOs of the PSUs. However, globally deteriorating market conditions ruined those ambitions forcing the government to postpone their plans, and managed only Rs. 11.45 billion (not even 3% of the target). To add to the woes, slowing economic growth (especially industrial production growth) coupled with a distressing rise in trade deficit (slowing exports due to global slowdown & rising imports due to growth in Indian consumption) is surely going to result in a lower than expected tax collection. And did I mention the depreciating rupee, which has not only hurt the corporate sector (thanks to their dollar borrowings & imported inputs), but also our national kitty (oil, gold, and coal)?

Simply put, these indicators are suggesting that the government has faced a rough year since it has had to deal with lower income (missed divestment targets, declining tax revenues) but higher expenses (weaker rupee and increased subsidy spending) than it had anticipated when proposing the annual budget. Such a bleak economic picture, on both, monetary & fiscal facets, could dishearten even the most optimist policymakers. While the picture is not a pretty one, it has been painted using a brush of newspaper headlines. In my next post, I will mention some reasons why I feel India, despite its issues, is the place to be for the next decade.

Strong words for a place I have only been cynical about so far, but then again, I am a Cynical Bull !