Showing posts with label Currency. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Currency. Show all posts

27 Jan 2012

India Macroeconomic Snapshot 2011

 
For almost 2 years, India’s Central Bank has been busy battling Inflation, even at the cost of Economic Growth. However, instead of being commended on their efforts to tame this stubbornly sticky inflation (which is clearly a product of Supply Constraints and Fiscal Mismanagement), the RBI has been heavily criticized for the slowdown in GDP growth.
In response to the slowdown, the RBI cut the Cash Reserve Ratio – the percentage of deposits that banks must keep with the central bank – by 50 bps (0.5%) in its review on Jan 24, a move that would release Rs. 32,000 Cr ($ 6.5 billion) into financial system. In his policy statement, RBI governor D. Subharao said, “the growth-inflation balance of the monetary policy stance has now shifted to growth, while at the same time ensuring that inflationary pressures remain contained”.
Slowing GDP Growth
According to the official estimates, the GDP grew at a mere 6.9%, compared to 8.4% in the previous year. The slowdown was mainly driven by the manufacturing sector, where growth slowed down from 7.8% last fiscal to a meager 2.7%. Other sectors have fared poorly as well with the Industrial output slipping into negative territory at -5.1% in October before bouncing back to 6.8% in November, mostly on account of a large base-effect. Strapped for funds, core infrastructure sector too saw dismal growth at 0.3%, owing to poor execution of projects.
Inflationary Pressures
Averaging around 9%, throughout the year 2011, headline inflation has been well above the comfort levels of the Government and RBI. While their desired range for headline inflation is 5 – 5.5 %, that range has continuously been breached every year since 2005 – 2006. However, much to everybody’s relief, Food inflation declined to lowest in 6 years (6 years – what a coincidence) albeit thanks to a strong base-effect, and seasonal impact. Since monetary actions take about 4-6 months to show results in the economy, there is some respite for 2012 for inflation to be contained. However, considering the risk of oil prices spiking up, the Central Bank will have to be extremely careful and ensure that inflationary headwinds have genuinely subsided before adopting any stimulus measures throughout 2012.
Burgeoning Fiscal and Current Account Deficits
Another alarming issue for the economy has been its mounting fiscal deficit. The previous Union Budget (FY 2011-2012) had set a target of the fiscal deficit at 4.6% of GDP. However, the fiscal deficit during the first half the fiscal alone was 85.6% of the full-year target. Hence, it is quite clear that the government is set to miss the target, and the deficit is more likely to be around the 5.2% mark, or perhaps more if oil prices rise and/or tax revenues decline (I believe that both events are highly likely, and a deficit of around 5.6% or more should not come as a surprise). With tax collections sluggish, and divestment ambitions foiled by poor market conditions, the government has no option but to borrow more to pay for its ever-growing subsidies bill. In doing so, it essentially mopped up most of the funds in the market, and crowded out private sector investments (i.e. increased interest rates by excess borrowing in the money markets). Rising oil and fertilizer prices and the implementation of the Food Security Bill are all going to further increase the subsidy burden for the government. With a tax base of less than 10% of the GDP, the picture doesn’t look very bright.
To make matters worse, high interest rates, big-ticket scandals, and the government’s reform-inertia had dampened the business environment to such an extent that manufacturing and industrial production plummeted. Exports growth was very trivial (due to economic slowdown in major export destinations), and was merely a fraction of the sharp growth in imports (thanks to robust domestic consumption demand), thereby worsening the trade balance. In addition to the worsening trade-balance, imports of Oil and a huge appetite for Gold (India imported 969 Tons in 2011) dented the Current Account Deficit even further. In fact, Oil and Gold together account for about 70% of the nation’s Current Account Deficit. Furthermore, high interest rates dampened corporate investments, and foreign capital inflows dried up too. All this put pressure on the nation’s foreign exchange reserves, which reflected on the Indian Rupee.
Currency Woes
2011 was a challenging year for the Indian Rupee, which depreciated 16% in 2011 (its biggest annual fall since 2008) and was the worst performing Asian currency of the year. Concerns about the rising fiscal and current account deficits amidst an uncertain global environment, loss of confidence in the Indian reform process, doubts over its growth momentum and stubbornly high inflation led foreign institutions (FIIs) to sell the Indian currency, pushing it to an all-time low of 54.30 against the US Dollar in the December.
The RBI refused to deploy India’s foreign exchange reserves to curtail this slide, as it was not a phenomenon that monetary action could fix alone. So RBI used alternative methods to curb speculation on the Rupee. It banned firms to enter multiple forward contracts to cover a single foreign currency transaction, and also eased rules for companies to raise offshore debt. It also raised the interest rates payable on deposits made by Non-Resident Indians. Also in December, India and Japan signed a $ 15 billion currency swap agreement. The RBI has pledged to keep a close eye on Rupee levels throughout 2012 as a weak rupee would further hurt imports, and on the flipside, exports won’t benefit much either owing to a global slowdown. In fact, firms that had resorted to foreign-currency debt in the form of External Commercial Borrowings, or ECBs (against a backdrop of rising interest rates in India), had to face tremendous pressure servicing that debt with the Rupee at such depressed levels. All in all, a weak currency would hence only add more inflationary pressure on the Indian economy.
Dominated by negative news-flow, such as the FDI in Retail debacle, or missed Divestment targets, criticisms of Policy Paralysis, failure of introducing GST, etc., 2011 was a year to forget for several investors, business leaders, and parliamentarians alike. So as we enter 2012, many “experts” will be hoping for the Union Budget in March to introduce crucial economic reforms. However, the challenges now are more complicated than they have been in recent years. Too much emphasis has been given to the role of RBI’s monetary policy, discounting the importance of the Finance Ministry (Fiscal Policy) in driving the economy. Personally, I expect FY13 to be much choppier than last year, and expect things to get much worse before getting any better. Considering the nature of coalition politics in India, any reform announced during the budget would come as a surprise, albeit a positive one.

3 Dec 2011

Real Life Lessons that Economics Can Teach Us All




I often find people dismissing Economics as being "impractical", 'unscientific" or "idealistic", and when I try to debate otherwise, I get some heated arguments, most of them being along the lines of its inability to 'truly reflect the reality'. Considering that economic theories are formulated with a peculiar assumption of 
Ceteris Paribus, a Latin phrase that translates to 'holding all other factors constant', I do not blame the skeptics. Regardless, I believe that Economics is still a science, which emerged from the notion of scarcity, and I think it teaches some important lessons on life. Let me mention some of them. 


1. Expectations: Expectations about the future causes businesses and households (participants of the economy) to adjust their consumption, saving, investment and expenditure patterns accordingly, and these subsequently influence economic variables.

Let’s look at an example, within the Indian context to see how this works. In an inflationary environment, expectations of future inflation could become a self-fulfilling prophecy. For instance, if workers expect future inflation, they are more likely to demand higher wages to compensate for the increased costs of living. If their management gives in to their demands, the higher wages would increase the cost of the product / service that the firm sells. Moreover, the firm, in anticipation of higher inflation will increase the costs further to maintain adequate profit margins. Essentially, the higher costs will be passed on to the consumers causing what is known as Cost-Push Inflation. On the other hand, the workers who now have more disposable income will demand for more (or higher quality) goods and services. If the supply remains at the same, the prices will go up thereby causing inflation of a different kind – Demand-Pull Inflation.

Key Lesson: Expectations influence Actions, and hence Outcomes. If you believe you will succeed / fail at any endeavor, chances are, you're making another self-fulfilling prophecy. Thus, as the spiritual gurus say, stay positive !


2. Externalities: Externalities are spillover consequences (often non-monetary) of a transaction, experienced by unrelated 3rd parties. These could be positive (read: social benefits) or negative (read: social costs), and could potentially lead to market failure if the social costs are not compensated for. On the other hand, social benefits tend to add to the business' goodwill. 

For example, schools, universities and research institutes emit positive externalities as education generates social benefits in addition to the profits for the institute selling the service (of education). Therefore, it’s a common feature in advanced economies for governments to either subsidize education or give incentives to education providers for the social benefit they bring about. On the other hand, large investment banks have been heavily criticized for taking on unsustainable amounts of debt leading to the Global Financial Crisis of 2007-08, and also amplifying the systemic risk in the overall banking system. These actions of investment banks (due to poor regulation) had brought about severe negative externalities that have now triggered in widespread social unrest (read: Occupy Wall Street).

Key Lesson: Your actions always have unintended consequences. Well-intended actions can sometimes have unintended ill side-effects too, and vice-versa. You can never be cautious enough. 


3. Dead-weight Loss: Dead-weight loss (DWL) refers to the monetary/welfare costs to society that are caused by market inefficiency, mostly arising due to poor policies or misallocation of resources. When a market is in equilibrium (i.e. demand = supply), there is no DWL. However, when price controls (minimum wage, subsidy, etc) are introduced, the demand & supply dynamics change and the new equilibrium point create a dead-weight loss. 

For example, imposing taxes on any particular product / service would not only reduce the seller's profits, but also cause some customers to shy away from making that purchase due to a higher price, thereby further reducing the profitability of the seller. In another scenario, imposing price controls (such as minimum wage & price ceilings) tends to restrict the businesses from functioning optimally, and creating DWL in the process. This loss of efficiency is then passed on to the consumer in the form of higher prices. In both cases, there is deadweight loss arising in terms of the monetary loss of profit for the seller, and in terms of the loss of utility derived from that particular product to the customer. 

Key Lesson: Let nature take its course, and only intervene when those forces are on a collision course, and external action is a must. Natural forces have a way of finding their own equilibrium.


4. Opportunity Cost: Opportunity cost is the cost of the action that has to be forgone, when opting for an alternative action, thereby highlighting the relationship between 'scarcity' and 'choices'. It is important to understand that the underlying assumption is that resources (time/money/labor) are limited and therefore there is always a trade-off on how to deploy those resources at any given point in time. One must note that the opportunity cost of an action may not necessarily be monetary in nature.

For example, instead of reading this post, you could have been baking a cake, washing your car, shopping, working, etc. Here, your opportunity cost is in terms of time (scarce resource), which could have been used for many possible activities (choice), and in the trade-off, you chose to read this post (excellent choice). In another instance, an investor decides that investments to make based on his capital and the available opportunities (both being scarce resources), and his decision (trade-off) is based on the pay-offs of each investment opportunity (returns, risk levels, etc). At the end of the day, one can use a $ 1 million to deploy at the stock markets, a new house, at a new business venture, or be used up for buying flashy goods, or be given to charity, etc.

Key Lesson: Our lives are determined by the choices we make, and while our options may seem limited, we must compare their Opportunity Costs to make the right decisions. 


5. Diminishing Marginal Utility: The Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility, in simple words, says that as an individual consumes more and more units of a product/service, the utility (read: satisfaction) derived from each consecutive unit, after a certain number of units, tends to decline. This concept applies to a production setting to, and a manufacturer may find his marginal utility diminishing by producing more units.

For example, Toyota currently manufactures 1000 cares a day. But to manufacture more cars per day, it will need to hire more workers, which will require more space to work, and also more wages to pay out. This may no longer be efficient because it may raise the average cost of producing one car. Hence producing more than the 1001st car (and every car after that) will have diminishing marginal utility.  Similarly, consider a situation where you are very thirsty, and you drink water. Your 1st glass will be very satisfying, but your second glass, though much needed, will not offer the same satisfaction as the 1st one, and hence, will have lower marginal utility.

Key Lesson: More isn’t always better. Excessive quantity more often than not tends to defeat the purpose and backfire. This also applies to things such as hard work and happiness, where excess can lead to health problems and therefore, a natural decline in efficiency.


6. Fiat Money: It is currency that has been declared by the government to serve as legal tender, but is not backed by any physical commodity such as gold, copper, grains, etc. Therefore, its value is not intrinsic, but based solely on the premise that the counterparty would accept it as means of payment for goods, services and debt (or taxes in case of the Government).

As most of you know (I hope) transactions historically were made using the Barter System. This evolved to using commodities (grains, precious metals) as currency, until the 11th century China, where the Yuan and Ming dynasties became pioneers of fiat currency. That being said, after the Nikon Oil Shock in 1971, almost all currencies in the world have been flat currencies. The problem with this is that since currencies are legal tenders backed solely by trust, it can become worthless due to hyperinflation if there is a loss of public confidence on owing to incessant printing of paper currency (the most recent victim of this was Zimbabwe).

Key Lesson: Always Have Faith. The moment you lose confidence, even the most prized assets – whether it is a skill, a person, or an object – become worthless.


13 Nov 2011

Surprise Surprise.. Targets Missed.. Again !!

The purpose of this post is to recognize & be able to connect various dots, and draw a clearer picture of the issues that paralyzing the Indian economy. My intention is merely to instigate a desire to comprehend issues that are rooted much deeper than what we read in our daily papers. In other words, I want to raise a few themes that I believe are all inter-related and probably, the root of several problems that the Indian economy faces. 

So for starters, let me remind you of the high inflation numbers that have hurt not just the poor, but also the middle-class – perhaps more than they have hurt the poor. Traditionally, I would have gone about this by researching for CPI & WPI statistics and analyze them from that point onwards. Instead, this time I chose to simply talk to people about where they felt the pinch of inflation the most personally, just to feel the pulse of the problem. Most common areas – as expected – were food, petrol, & housing. Consequentially, their utilities bill has gone up, and savings have been dented. We will look at each of these in greater detail later.  

Now let’s leave inflation & monetary policy transmission alone for a while and look at the fiscal policy facet of our economy. Let’s begin with a special mention of the various populist schemes our government has crafted to win the hearts of the nation’s vote bank. These include the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (aka NREGA), and the Minimum Support Price (MSP) given to farmers, & various subsidies on kerosene, diesel and gas, fertilizers, & food items, etc. With elections not too far away, there are more such populist schemes in the pipeline, and not surprisingly, the government has no clue of how the schemes are going to be paid for. The Finance Ministry’s had already used up 70% of the annual target of the fiscal deficit in September, and announced that it needed to borrow Rs. 528 billion. This means that while the fiscal deficit target presented during the annual budget was 4.6% of the GDP, it is more likely to be around 5.5% according to experts. However, our ever-optimistic government still maintains that they can keep it under 5%.

Furthermore, they claim that the additional borrowing has nothing to do with the fact that they have so far failed (anybody surprised?) in their plans to divest their stake in PSUs. The budgeted divestment target was Rs. 400 billion for the fiscal year, raised, primarily by issuing IPOs of the PSUs. However, globally deteriorating market conditions ruined those ambitions forcing the government to postpone their plans, and managed only Rs. 11.45 billion (not even 3% of the target). To add to the woes, slowing economic growth (especially industrial production growth) coupled with a distressing rise in trade deficit (slowing exports due to global slowdown & rising imports due to growth in Indian consumption) is surely going to result in a lower than expected tax collection. And did I mention the depreciating rupee, which has not only hurt the corporate sector (thanks to their dollar borrowings & imported inputs), but also our national kitty (oil, gold, and coal)?

Simply put, these indicators are suggesting that the government has faced a rough year since it has had to deal with lower income (missed divestment targets, declining tax revenues) but higher expenses (weaker rupee and increased subsidy spending) than it had anticipated when proposing the annual budget. Such a bleak economic picture, on both, monetary & fiscal facets, could dishearten even the most optimist policymakers. While the picture is not a pretty one, it has been painted using a brush of newspaper headlines. In my next post, I will mention some reasons why I feel India, despite its issues, is the place to be for the next decade.

Strong words for a place I have only been cynical about so far, but then again, I am a Cynical Bull !